How online instant offers from CarMax, Carvana and Peddle work, when they change, how you get paid, and how to weigh one against a dealer's trade-in. Last checked 2026-11-14.
Short answer: an instant offer is a real, written price for your car that's good for about a week, and you don't have to buy anything to get it. CarMax and Carvana both say their offers last 7 days and change only if the car doesn't match what you told them. That makes an offer the best floor you can bring to a dealer. Get one or two before you go. Then remember the one thing an outright sale can't give you: in most states, trading in toward your next car cuts the sales tax on it. On the $29,281 example car below, a Michigan trade-in saves about $720 of tax, so an instant offer has to beat the dealer by that much to come out ahead. Tradein isn't paid by any company named on this page.
You enter the VIN or plate, the mileage and a few condition questions, and the buyer shows a price within minutes. To redeem it you bring the car in (or have it picked up), someone checks that it matches what you said, and you sign the title over and get paid. Details differ by company:
| CarMax | Carvana | Peddle | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Offer lasts | 7 days | 7 days | Not stated |
| Must you buy? | No | No | No |
| Can it change? | If car differs | If car differs | If car differs a lot |
| Hand-over | Store; paid pickup some areas | Free drop-off; paid pickup | Free pickup |
| Paid by | Bank draft, same day | Check or ACH (2-5 days) | At pickup |
| Pays off loan | Yes | Yes | Not stated |
| Non-running | Case by case | Not stated | Yes |
Sources: CarMax, Sell my car FAQ, CarMax questions answered and How to sell your car to CarMax; Carvana, Sell or trade your car; Peddle, How it works and How free pickup works. All read 2026-11-14; companies change their terms, so check the offer page itself.
CarMax says its offer is the same whether or not you buy from it, and asks to see some cars in person. Peddle buys cars running or not. Two things in the fine print matter:
An instant offer and a trade-in are both a dealer buying your car wholesale, so they tend to land in the same neighborhood. What separates them:
So the comparison that's fair to both is: instant offer vs trade-in value + the tax the trade-in saves. If the instant offer still wins, sell it outright. If the dealer won't come close to the offer, you have your answer in writing. CarMax and Carvana will also take the car as a trade-in when you buy from them, which gets you the tax credit too.
Tradein's trade-in value starts from what dealers within 100 miles are asking for the same year, make and model, adjusts for your mileage, trim and condition, then takes off a typical dealer margin (7.8% of the list price) and a reconditioning estimate for your condition ($400 for excellent, $900 for good, $1,900 for fair, $3,500 for rough). It's an estimate of what a dealer can pay, built from listings you can check, not an offer. How we calculate it
Use it three ways:
How long is an instant cash offer good for? CarMax and Carvana both say 7 days. The Peddle pages we read don't state a period. The offer holds only if the car matches what you entered: each buyer checks the car when you bring it in or it's picked up.
Do I have to buy a car to get a CarMax or Carvana offer? No. CarMax says its offer is the same whether or not you buy from it, and Carvana will buy your car outright. If you do buy from the same company and trade the car in, most states then charge sales tax only on the difference.
Can an instant offer go down at inspection? Yes, if the car doesn't match the answers you gave. CarMax says it adjusts an offer only when its in-person check differs from what it was told; Carvana makes an updated offer if it finds a mismatch at the appointment; Peddle says the offer may change if the car differs significantly. Answering the condition questions honestly is the best way to keep the number.
Is an instant offer better than a dealer trade-in? Compare the offer with the trade-in value plus the sales tax the trade-in saves on your next car. On the $29,281 example car, a Michigan trade-in saves about $720, so an instant offer has to beat the dealer by that much. If it does, selling outright wins; if not, the trade-in does.
How do I get paid when I sell to CarMax, Carvana or Peddle? CarMax pays with a bank draft the same day, which must be deposited rather than cashed. Carvana pays by check or bank transfer at the appointment; it says transfers usually take 2 to 5 business days. Peddle pays at pickup. If you have a loan, CarMax and Carvana pay off your lender directly.
How we calculate it · Trade-in tax by state · What dealers make · Trade in or sell? · What dealers check · Owe more than it's worth? · Selling with a loan · Leased car? · Salvage or rebuilt title · Car color and value · Lost title? · Inherited a car? · Fix it first? · Mileage and value · Instant cash offers · Selling an EV · When to sell · Selling a car by state · Stop calls & texts