Skip to content
GarageAnswers

Are all-weather tires good in snow?

Updated 12 sources3 min read

Short answer

Yes. All-weather tires carry the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol, grip far better in snow than ordinary all-season tires, and the best ones come close to winter tires on packed snow. They still fall short of dedicated winter tires on ice and in deep or unplowed snow, so if you regularly drive on ice or in heavy snow, winter tires are still the safer pick.

Safety first. No tire makes ice safe. Slow down and leave much more following distance on snow and ice whatever tires you run, and check your tread: Consumer Reports suggests shopping for new tires at 4/32 inch, because snow grip drops off sharply as tread wears.

On this page

Step by step

  1. 1

    Look for the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol

    It's a small mountain with a snowflake inside, molded into the sidewall. All-weather tires and winter tires have it. 'M+S' (mud and snow) alone is not the same thing: Tire Rack notes M+S is based only on tread geometry, not a snow test.

  2. 2

    Be honest about your winters

    Tire Rack's guidance: all-season for winters that are mostly wet and cool with only occasional snow; all-weather if you regularly see snow and freezing temperatures but don't want two sets; dedicated winter tires if you regularly face deep snow or ice.

  3. 3

    Compare test results, not just the symbol

    The symbol is a pass/fail floor, and tires that pass it differ a lot. In Tire Rack's 2026 test, one all-weather tire stopped on snow within about a foot of the winter tires while another needed about 9 feet more than a performance winter tire. Read independent tests for the specific model.

  4. 4

    Check your local rules

    Some places require winter-rated tires in season. British Columbia says tires with the mountain/snowflake symbol 'include all-weather tires'. Quebec requires tires marked with the winter pictogram, or studded tires, from December 1 to March 15. Colorado's Traction Law accepts all-weather tires with at least 3/16 inch of tread.

  5. 5

    Keep enough tread

    Snow grip depends on deep, open tread. British Columbia requires at least 3.5 mm for a legal winter tire; Quebec recommends at least 4.8 mm in winter.

What the 2026 tests show

Tire Rack ran ten tires in size 215/55R17 on a 2025 Toyota Camry in near-freezing conditions (test dated March 2, 2026): five winter tires, three all-weather tires and two all-season tires. Numbers below are the ones Tire Rack states in its text.

Tire Type Snow stop from 25 mph Wet stop from 50 mph
Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 Winter 57.3 ft 117.6 ft
Bridgestone WeatherPeak All-weather 58.6 ft 110.7 ft
Continental VikingContact 8 Winter 59.3 ft 117.8 ft
Vredestein Wintrac Pro+ Performance winter 63.1 ft 100.2 ft
Michelin CrossClimate2 All-weather 72.4 ft 99.6 ft

Two things stand out:

  • The best all-weather tire was within about a foot of the winter tires when braking on packed snow, and it stopped shorter than them in the wet.
  • All-weather tires vary a lot. The CrossClimate2, which Tire Rack still calls “a four-season champion,” needed about 15 feet more than the WeatherPeak to stop on snow. The snowflake symbol tells you a tire cleared a minimum; it doesn’t rank tires.

Tire Rack’s overall take is that the all-weather tires showed “genuine snow capability,” but the winter tires “retained an advantage when conditions became more demanding,” and its best-all-weather guide says they “couldn’t consistently match the grip available from purpose-built winter rubber, particularly on ice.”

All-season vs all-weather vs winter

All-season All-weather Winter
Snowflake symbol Usually no (often M+S only) Yes Yes
Packed snow Fair Good, best models near winter tires Best
Ice Weakest Better than all-season Best
Wet and dry Good Good Often less grip than all-season (Consumer Reports)
Stay on all year Yes Yes No: they wear faster in warm weather
Best for Mild winters, occasional light snow Regular snow and freezing temps, one set of tires Regular deep snow, ice, unplowed or mountain roads

Where the sources disagree

  • How close is “close”? Consumer Reports says all-weather tires “come close enough for most needs.” Tire makers quoted by Modern Tire Dealer in 2023 are more skeptical: Nexen said a snowflake-rated tire “has nowhere near the traction and control of a dedicated winter tire,” and Continental said all-weather tires “perform much closer to this minimum standard.” Tire Rack’s own 2026 numbers show both are possible depending on the model.
  • The test threshold. Tire Rack gives the snowflake threshold as 110 against the 14-inch reference tire, or 112 against the 16-inch one; some tire makers quote only one of those numbers.
  • What counts as a winter tire legally. British Columbia’s page names all-weather tires as qualifying; Quebec’s and Transport Canada’s pages don’t mention all-weather tires and point to the snowflake pictogram instead.

Common follow-up questions

What's the difference between all-weather and all-season tires?

All-weather tires carry the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol, meaning they passed a standard snow-traction test; most all-season tires don't. Tire Rack describes all-weather tires as the middle ground between all-season and dedicated winter tires, designed to stay on all year.

Are all-weather tires as good as winter tires?

Close on packed snow for the best models, but not on ice. Consumer Reports says they 'typically don't match' dedicated winter tires 'but they come close enough for most needs.' Tire Rack says winter tires 'remain the benchmark' for deep snow, packed ice and unplowed mountain roads.

What does the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol actually test?

Acceleration traction on medium-packed snow only, under the ASTM F1805 spin test. A tire must score at least 110 against a reference tire rated 100 (112 with the 16-inch reference tire). Braking and turning on snow, and ice grip, are not part of the test, according to Tire Rack.

Are all-weather tires good on ice?

Better than regular all-seasons, but this is where dedicated winter tires pull ahead most. The snowflake test has no ice component, and Transport Canada notes there's no government minimum standard for winter tire performance on ice in Canada, the US or the EU.

Can I leave all-weather tires on all year?

Yes, that's what they're designed for. Consumer Reports says most buyers come out ahead by skipping the cost and hassle of seasonal changes, even though some all-weather tires cost more than the all-seasons they replace.

Are all-weather tires worse in the rain?

Not necessarily. In Tire Rack's 2026 test on near-freezing wet pavement, the Bridgestone WeatherPeak all-weather stopped from 50 mph in 110.7 feet, shorter than the Blizzak WS90 winter tire at 117.6 feet.

Do all-weather tires count as winter tires for the law?

Often, yes. British Columbia and Colorado's Traction Law both accept them. Quebec's rule is the winter tire pictogram or studs; its page doesn't mention all-weather tires by name, so check the sidewall for the pictogram.

Do I still need winter tires if I have all-wheel drive and all-weather tires?

AWD helps you get moving, not stop or turn. If you regularly drive on ice or unplowed roads, dedicated winter tires are still the bigger safety gain. See our winter tires vs all-season answer for braking numbers.

Sources

  1. 1.Tire Rack: All-Season vs. All-Weather Tires: What's the Difference? (Sep 21, 2026)
  2. 2.Tire Rack: What Are All-Weather Tires?
  3. 3.Tire Rack: What is the Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake Symbol?
  4. 4.Tire Rack test: All-Weather vs. Winter Tires: The Definitive Test (2026)
  5. 5.Tire Rack: Best All-Weather Tires for 2026 (Oct 5, 2026)
  6. 6.Consumer Reports: Best All-Weather Tires (updated Oct 1, 2026)
  7. 7.Consumer Reports: Best Winter/Snow Tires (updated Oct 1, 2026)
  8. 8.Modern Tire Dealer: Is 3-Peak Mountain Snowflake the Ultimate in Winter Tire Certification? (Mar 2023)
  9. 9.Government of British Columbia: Passenger Vehicle Tire and Chain Requirements
  10. 10.Gouvernement du Québec: Requirements for winter tires (Oct 5, 2026)
  11. 11.Transport Canada: Winter Tires briefing note (Nov 2019)
  12. 12.CDOT: Chain Up Tips for Passenger & Small Commercial Vehicles

General information only, not a diagnosis. Your owner’s manual comes first. How we write these

Related questions